Small Area Estimation and Hotspot Analysis

Bayesian spatial modeling for HIV, Syphilis, Chlamydia, and Gonorrhea in the Southeast United States
Keywords

sexually transmitted infections, STI, STD, syphilis, epidemiology, public health, Southeast United States, surveillance, trends, spatial analysis, Bayesian modeling, small area estimation

Bayesian Areal Data Models and Hotspot Analysis

This analysis uses Bayesian areal data models to identify spatial hotspots for sexually transmitted infections (STIs) in the Southeast United States. Small area estimation techniques allow us to identify counties where disease rates are elevated beyond what would be expected from population size alone, accounting for spatial autocorrelation. See the Methods page for more details.

For each sexually transmitted infection, we examine the county-level spatial effect to determine if there are any counties with elevated disease rates that are not explained by population size alone and spatial correlation indicating a potential hotspot.

Available results for: hiv, syphilis, ct, gc 

HIV Prevalence

Below are maps of the observed rate, spatial effect, and identified hotspots for HIV prevalence in 2023.

Summary Statistics

Observed Rates:

  • Mean: 380.18 per 100,000
  • Median: 309.20 per 100,000
  • Range: 62.60 - 2380.90 per 100,000

Spatial Effects: - Mean: 0.0025 - Std Dev: 0.6146 - Range: -1.4057 - 1.9546

Hotspots: - Number: 44 (10.1% of counties) - Threshold: 0.7721

Primary and Secondary Syphilis

Summary Statistics

Observed Rates: - Mean: 18.07 per 100,000 - Median: 14.10 per 100,000 - Range: 0.00 - 103.80 per 100,000

Spatial Effects: - Mean: 0.0013 - Std Dev: 0.5608 - Range: -1.3755 - 1.7046

Hotspots: - Number: 44 (10.0% of counties) - Threshold: 0.7540

Chlamydia (CT)

Summary Statistics

Observed Rates: - Mean: 554.09 per 100,000 - Median: 494.60 per 100,000 - Range: 92.10 - 2730.00 per 100,000

Spatial Effects: - Mean: 0.0014 - Std Dev: 0.5332 - Range: -1.4538 - 1.7025

Hotspots: - Number: 44 (10.0% of counties) - Threshold: 0.6824

Gonorrhea (GC)

Summary Statistics

Observed Rates: - Mean: 205.61 per 100,000 - Median: 172.60 per 100,000 - Range: 0.00 - 1342.10 per 100,000

Spatial Effects: - Mean: 0.0020 - Std Dev: 0.7007 - Range: -2.3950 - 2.0507

Hotspots: - Number: 44 (10.0% of counties) - Threshold: 0.8520

Comparison Across Diseases

Spatial random effects represent deviations from the overall mean rate that cannot be explained by population size alone. Positive spatial effects indicate areas with elevated disease rates after accounting for population, while negative effects indicate lower-than-expected rates.



Table: Hotspot Summary by Disease

|Disease   | Counties| Hotspots| % Hotspots| Mean Rate| Mean Spatial Effect|
|:---------|--------:|--------:|----------:|---------:|-------------------:|
|Chlamydia |      439|       44|       10.0|     554.1|              0.0014|
|Gonorrhea |      439|       44|       10.0|     205.6|              0.0020|
|HIV       |      437|       44|       10.1|     380.2|              0.0025|
|Syphilis  |      439|       44|       10.0|      18.1|              0.0013|

Comparison of spatial random effects and hotspots across diseases

Comparison of spatial random effects and hotspots across diseases

Comparison of spatial random effects and hotspots across diseases

Comparison of spatial random effects and hotspots across diseases

Overlap of spatial hotspots

In the below map, we examine the overlap of spatial hotspots for each sexually transmitted infection. We see that there is a moderate amount of overlap, with some counties being hotspots for multiple diseases. This could suggest that there are shared risk factors or transmission networks across these diseases.

Major interstate highways are shown in blue.

Overlap of spatial hotspots for each sexually transmitted infection

Overlap of spatial hotspots for each sexually transmitted infection